Time for another DVD Dump Bin entry! This month Phantom goes all out and spends a whopping $7.50 on this month's film, found in a "Get Drunk Even If You're Not Irish" St. Patrick's Day display among such Irish Classics as the Boondock Saints II
and Family Guy
Volume 5.

By Phantom
Alistair Little (Liam Neeson as an adult, Mark Davison as a youth) joins a Protestant paramilitary group in Northern Ireland as a reaction to what he felt was baseless Catholic aggression. After killing a Catholic dockworker who threatened Protestant co-worker, Alistair winds up in jail for murder. Many years later, a changed Alistair is scheduled to meet Joe Griffin (James Nesbitt as an adult, Kevin O' Neill as a youth), the brother of the murdered dockworker, for a TV show about reconciliation. The film is divided up into roughly three acts. The first act depicts the murder and the events that led up to it. The second act focuses on the two prepping to meet on television. The final act depicts the life of the two after the television program. It’s difficult to describe all the acts without giving out too many plot details and although they are distinct, the acts are clearly linked. The segues aren’t jarring as much as they are unconventional… which is to be applauded but again difficult to describe concisely.
Thematically,
Five Minutes of Heaven is kind of the anti-vigilante picture, which is kind of interesting since Neeson scored box office gold with the vigilante picture Taken a year earlier. However, instead of vengeance killings taking on a cathartic role for the vigilante, killings here take a heavy toll on the soul. Of course the situations are slightly different than those presented in the traditional vigilante picture. In traditional vigilante pictures, the hero is greatly wronged by a petty criminal who goes too far and commits murder, wronging the protagonist. In
Five Minutes of Heaven, the context is that of the Northern Ireland “Troubles” between Protestant Unionists and Catholic Nationalists. Since the film doesn't get into specifics, the conflict could easily be any one where retribution is constantly handed back and forth. The film doesn’t really get into all of the details of the Troubles, just that it was Catholics vs. Protestants and both the perpetrator and victim of a violent act carried that act with them for years. I suppose the film could be knocked for not providing a lot of sociopolitical background, but the film is really just a character study about two guys forever linked by a single act of violence.
Liam Neeson does a fine job, as does James Nesbitt. There is a bit of speechifying from the character of adult Alistair, though fortunately they are given a deft hand by Neeson and an appropriate context (a television interview and in counseling sessions to be precise). Whereas Alistair gets to tell his feeling to the Camera, Joe gets a few voice over monologs. Nesbitt has the more demanding role, with his character having to contain fear, anger and sorrow into one anxious mess. All the other characters, even Joe's wife who he pushes around in one scene, are peripheral players without a lot of characterization, keeping the focus on the two’s internal struggles. Director Oliver Hirschbiegel who is best known for
Downfall (if you’ve spent any amount of time on YouTube you’ve probably seen a “Hitler Parody” utilizing a clip of that film), keeps the film at a good pace and holds the three disparate acts into one cohesive film. The screenplay was written by Guy Hibbert.
Five Minutes of Heaven is a well acted, technically proficient film that has a valuable, if understated theme. However, the film is missing a certain “something” to really push it into the upper echelon of great films. Recommended.
© 2011 beyond the films